California FAIR Plan Rates Jump 29.1% on October 15: Why Now Is the Time to Re-Shop Your Home Insurance

Starting October 15, 2026, California FAIR Plan dwelling rates go up by an average of 29.1% for new and renewing policies. If you're one of the more than 675,000 Californians on the FAIR Plan, this is the largest increase in the plan's recent history, and it lands at your next renewal.

The good news: for the first time in years, standard insurers are actively looking to write homes again. Here's what's changing, what it could cost you, and why now is the right time to see if you can get off the FAIR Plan.

What's changing on October 15

• 29.1% average increase. The California Department of Insurance approved the hike after the FAIR Plan asked for 35.8% in a September 2025 filing. (Mountain Messenger, KQED)

• It hits at renewal. Existing policyholders pay the new rate when their policy renews on or after October 15. (KMPH / FOX 26)

• High-risk areas pay the most. Some homeowners in high wildfire-risk areas could see their wildfire premiums double, while some lower-risk urban policies may see decreases. (KQED)

• A first under the new rules. This is the first FAIR Plan rate filing reviewed under California's Sustainable Insurance Strategy. (Mountain Messenger)

What 29.1% looks like in real dollars

At the statewide average, here's how much a FAIR Plan premium would go up per year. Your actual change depends on your home, location and coverage.

Current FAIR Plan premium	Increase at 29.1%	New annual premium
$2,000	+$582	$2,582
$3,000	+$873	$3,873
$5,000	+$1,455	$6,455
$9,000	+$2,619	$11,619

That's before the separate "difference in conditions" (DIC) policy most FAIR Plan customers buy to cover theft, water damage and liability. Nearly half of FAIR Plan customers carry a second policy to fill those gaps, according to Stanford researchers. (Stanford) If you don't have a DIC, see why here: What Is a DIC Policy? Why CA FAIR Plan Homeowners Need One

Why rates are going up

• The FAIR Plan has ballooned. As of March 2026 it held 684,388 policies, up 152% since September 2022, with $750 billion in exposure. (Mountain Messenger)

• The 2025 LA fires. The Palisades and Eaton fires produced 4,794 FAIR Plan claims and $914 million in payouts, and regulators approved a $1 billion assessment on member insurers, the first in more than 30 years. (Mountain Messenger)

• The whole market is more expensive. Average California homeowners premiums rose 84% between late 2020 and March 2026, and the FAIR Plan's share of single-family homes grew from 1.5% to about 5%. (Stanford)

The good news: standard carriers are coming back

Under the Sustainable Insurance Strategy, insurers can use wildfire catastrophe models and reinsurance costs in their rates. In exchange, they commit to writing more homes in wildfire-distressed areas. That trade is starting to open doors:

• Major carriers are lifting caps. In May 2026, one of California's largest home insurers fully removed its monthly cap on new homeowners policies, and six of the state's 10 largest home insurance groups have now committed to stay and grow. (CA Department of Insurance)

• More carriers are committing to grow. As of July 2026, the Department of Insurance reports 11 home insurance groups committed to stay and grow in California, plus new and expanding carriers targeting homes now on the FAIR Plan. (CA Department of Insurance)

• FAIR Plan growth is slowing. The plan added about 16,000 residential policies in Q1 2026, compared with 35,000 to 50,000 per quarter from 2024 into 2025. (CA Department of Insurance)

"We have markets that didn't exist a month ago." — Karl Susman, insurance broker, to KQED

Why you should re-shop before your renewal

1. Your total cost may have flipped. A FAIR Plan policy plus a DIC policy, both going up, can now cost more than a single standard homeowners policy that covers everything in one place.

2. Better coverage, one policy. A standard policy typically bundles fire, theft, water damage and liability. The FAIR Plan is a limited, last-resort policy.

3. Your home may qualify now when it didn't before. Carriers that paused new business a year or two ago are writing again, and home-hardening upgrades like a Class A roof, ember-resistant vents and defensible space can help you qualify or earn discounts.

4. Timing matters. The new rate applies at your renewal. Starting 45 to 60 days before it gives you time to compare options without a gap in coverage.

What to do now

• Find your FAIR Plan renewal date and your current premium.

• Pull the declarations pages for your FAIR Plan and any DIC policy.

• Make a list of upgrades you've done: roof, vents, windows, defensible space.

• Have an independent broker "US" shop the standard market before you renew.

That last step is where we come in. AEC Insurance Services is a family-run brokerage in Thousand Oaks. We compare carriers for you, give you a straight answer on whether your home can leave the FAIR Plan, and never submit an application without your OK.

See if my home qualifies

Prefer to talk? Call Albert, Chris or Justin at 805.328.5001.

---

Sources

• KQED: California FAIR Plan announces 29.1% rate hike for homeowners this fall (Aug. 2026)

• KMPH / FOX 26: California FAIR Plan customers face 29% average rate hike (Sept. 2026)

• The Mountain Messenger: FAIR Plan rates set to rise in October (June 2026)

• Orange County Register via Consumer Watchdog: FAIR Plan rates going up 29.1% in late 2026 (May 2026)

• Stanford Report: California's home insurance crisis is spreading beyond wildfire country (June 2026)

• CA Department of Insurance: California's second-largest home insurer joins Sustainable Insurance Strategy (May 12, 2026)

• CA Department of Insurance: Insurance surge expanding options for Californians in wildfire distressed areas (July 23, 2026)

This article is for general information only and isn't a quote or coverage advice. Rates, eligibility and availability vary by property and carrier, and not all homes qualify.